The debate between a metal roof and a shingle roof is a common one, for good reason.
The debate between a metal roof and a shingle roof is a common one, for good reason. The materials you use to put a roof on your house will have an impact on several things including cost, aesthetics, durability, and weather resistance.
There are advantages and drawbacks to both types of materials, which is why it is important to consider all of the factors and make an informed decision on which is the best option for you.
This guide aims to set out the pros and cons of metal roofs and shingle roofs for Texas homes, helping homeowners like you make informed choices that align with their needs and preferences.
Metal Roof vs Shingles: Cost Comparison
Roofing, or re-roofing, your house is a costly exercise. Therefore, the primary consideration for homeowners when choosing which option is best is often the metal roof cost compared to the shingle roof cost.
The difference in cost not only lies in the upfront cost but also the costs involved with long-term maintenance. While the upfront metal roof cost is typically higher compared to shingle roof cost, they offer long-term savings and durability.
The average metal roof cost ranges from $7 to $12 per square foot, including installation, while the shingle roof cost is a bit lower, ranging from $4 to $6 per square foot, making it more affordable.
However, it's essential to consider the lifespan of each roofing material when evaluating costs. Consider asking a professional how long does a metal roof last, compared to a shingle roof. Metal roofs last longer than shingle roofs making them more cost-effective over the long term as they require less long-term maintenance.
Durability and Longevity
Durability is another crucial factor to consider. In places like Texas, where severe weather conditions such as hailstorms and high winds are common, you might want to consider hail-resistant metal roofing as opposed to shingles.
Metal roofs are renowned for their exceptional durability and resistance to extreme weather events. High-quality metal roofing materials are engineered to withstand hail, wind gusts of up to 140 miles per hour, and fire, making them an excellent choice for Texas homeowners seeking long-lasting protection for their homes.
In contrast, shingle roofs may be more susceptible to damage from hail, wind, and fire, especially if they are made of asphalt or other less resilient materials. While some shingle manufacturers offer hail-resistant options, they may come at a higher cost and still not provide the same level of durability as metal roofing.
Aesthetics and Design
Aesthetics play a significant role in the metal roof vs shingles debate, as they contribute to the overall curb appeal and value of a home.
Metal roofs come in a variety of styles, including standing seam, metal tiles, and metal roof shingles that mimic the look of traditional roofing materials such as slate, wood, or clay tiles. This versatility, and the ability for homeowners to choose a metal roof that looks like shingles allows homeowners to achieve the desired aesthetic while benefiting from the durability and longevity of metal roofing.
Shingle roofs also offer a range of design options, with various colors, textures, and styles available to complement different architectural styles and preferences. Asphalt shingles remain the most popular choice for residential roofing in Texas due to their affordability and versatility. However, homeowners may need to replace or repair shingles more frequently to maintain the appearance of their roofs over time.
Installation and Maintenance Considerations
Installation and maintenance requirements are essential factors to consider when comparing a metal roof vs shingles.
Metal roofs typically require professional installation due to their specialized techniques and equipment, which can increase the upfront cost of a metal roof vs shingles. However, the installation process is generally faster and more straightforward compared to shingle roofs, which may require more labor and time to complete.
Maintenance requirements for metal roofs are minimal, with occasional inspections and cleaning recommended to ensure optimal performance and longevity. In contrast, shingle roofs may require regular maintenance, including inspections, repairs, and replacements of damaged or missing shingles, especially after severe weather events.
Ultimately, both the installation and maintenance of metal roofs are less time-consuming and less costly than shingles. This, along with the difference in the upfront cost of metal vs shingles will provide you with some good reasons to choose a metal roof over shingles.
Environmental Considerations
Environmental impact is becoming increasingly important for homeowners seeking sustainable roofing options. Metal roofs are highly sustainable, with most materials being recyclable and energy-efficient.
Metal roofing reflects solar heat, reducing energy consumption and cooling costs during hot Texas summers. Additionally, metal roofs can be installed over existing roofs in some cases, reducing waste and environmental impact.
On the other hand, asphalt shingles contribute to landfill waste and may contain harmful chemicals that can leach into the environment over time.
However, some shingle manufacturers offer eco-friendly options made from recycled materials or sustainable sources, providing homeowners with more environmentally conscious choices.
Answers to Some of the Most Asked Questions
1. How long does a metal roof last?
Metal roofs last between 40 - 70 years with proper maintenance. This means they have a significantly longer lifespan compared to shingle roofs which typically last 15 to 30 years.
2. Can you put a metal roof over shingles?
The short answer is yes. Most of the time, it is safe to install a metal roof over existing shingles that are showing signs of wear and tear (or even if they are still in good condition). However, it is always best to get an assessment done by a professional beforehand.
3. Is metal roofing hail resistant?
Metal roofing is highly resistant to damage. This means that although it can, like all types of roofing, be damaged, it is a less likely result when doing a metal roof vs shingles comparison.
Shingles may not generally be hail-resistant, but you are able to get specific hail-resistant shingles albeit at a slightly higher price.
4. How much is a metal roof?
On average, the metal roof cost is between $13,000 and $15,000 with the lowest price being around $8,500, and the highest being just under $70000. This includes the necessary materials and installation costs for the average-sized roof.
Whereas, the average shingle roof cost is between $12,000 and $14,000. With the lowest cost being around $8,500 and the highest being around $50,000. Again, including materials and installation costs for the average-sized roof.
In summary, choosing between a metal roof and a shingle roof for your Texas home can be tricky. It requires careful consideration of various factors, but the benefits of a metal roof vs shingles are hard to deny. The initial cost of shingle roofs may be slightly lower than the metal roof cost but metal roofs last longer, are more durable and are weather resistant. Shingle roofs are more affordable initially but may require more frequent maintenance and replacement over time.
The best roofing option for your home will ultimately depend on your budget, style preferences, and the local climate of the place where your home is. By weighing the pros and cons of metal and shingle roofs and consulting with a reputable roofing contractor, you can make an informed decision that provides lasting protection and enhances the beauty and value of your Texas home.